SUV vs Minivan: Which One Should You Choose?

Sedans are great for young couples, mainly due to their fuel efficiency. However, they may not be very practical after you welcome two or more kids. SUVs and minivans are the most popular family vehicles. They boast more interior room and cargo space than sedans, making it more comfortable for you, your passengers, and your belongings to get on the road.

Nevertheless, deciding whether to buy an SUV or a minivan can be tricky. Both vehicle classes have significant advantages, but one may be better depending on how you plan to use your car, your budget, and your lifestyle.

So, which one should you buy? Here is a guide comparing minivans vs. SUVs to help you decide which car is best for your family.

SUV vs minivan: What's the difference?

Sports utility vehicles (SUVs) are the most popular type of cars in the U.S. A study by iSeeCars revealed that in some states like Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and New York, SUVs account for over 50% of the state's vehicle share. Conversely, minivans are the least appealing type of vehicle in the American market. The top two states with the highest minivan share are Hawaii and Nebraska, comprising 5.3% and 4.9% of the vehicle share, respectively.

Knowing the difference between an SUV and a minivan is essential before choosing the best car for your family. Here are a few key features of both cars and where each type excels.

Interior space

If you have a large family, the minivan is the undisputed champion. They boast generous legroom, headroom, and comfortable seating for seven or eight passengers. Even the third-row seats are often usable for adults, with over five additional inches compared to an SUV. This is vital if you have teen kids or often travel with other adults. Moreover, some minivans offer second-row captain's chairs for added comfort and flexibility.

Nonetheless, SUVs are quite spacious, particularly the larger ones. However, although midsize SUVs can still accommodate the said number of passengers, they may not be comfortable for longer trips.

Cargo space

Minivans are built with space for passengers and cargo in mind. With all seats upright, minivans have more cargo space than most SUVs. This is a significant advantage for families who need to haul a lot of gear, groceries, or sports equipment.

When the seats fold down, minivans transform into cavernous cargo holds, perfect for road trips or hauling large items. Many minivans offer multiple seating configurations and removable seats, allowing you to maximize space for passengers, cargo, or both.

Cargo capacity in SUVs can vary greatly depending on the size and model. While some larger SUVs offer decent cargo space with the seats folded, it rarely matches the versatility of a minivan's configurable space.

Safety

Minivans and SUVs have modern safety features like anti-lock brakes (ABS) and electronic stability control (ESC). Most models offer advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS), such as blind-spot monitoring, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking.

However, some drivers may prefer SUVs because they offer a better road view due to their larger size and higher seating position. Be sure to check the NHTSA safety ratings on either vehicle before buying.

Design

Minivans prioritize functionality over aesthetics, one reason most people don’t want to buy them. However, the design maximizes interior space and passenger comfort. The sliding doors also offer an advantage in tight parking spaces and eliminate the risk of passengers accidentally hitting parked cars with swinging doors.

On the other hand, an SUV is your best bet if you want luxury or a car to impress your girlfriend. They come in various styles, from sporty to rugged, so you'll certainly get something that blows your mind.

Driving experience

Minivans offer a smoother and more car-like driving experience. Their lower center of gravity results in better handling and stability, especially when fully loaded. Conversely, SUVs provide a higher driving position and a more commanding view of the road, similar to a truck.

Moreover, minivans are built for paved roads. Because of their low ground clearance, they will struggle on rough terrain or snowy conditions. On the other hand, SUVs, especially those with AWD and higher ground clearance, can handle off-road adventures or snowy roads more easily.

Features like four-wheel drive, skid plates, and hill descent control can be crucial for venturing off the beaten path. However, not all SUVs are created equal for off-roading. Be sure to choose an SUV with the appropriate features if venturing off-road is just as important.

Fuel efficiency

Due to their lighter weight and more aerodynamic design, minivans have better gas mileage than similarly sized SUVs. This can be a significant advantage for families who rack up many miles.

While there are some fuel-efficient SUV models, they are smaller and have less passenger and cargo space. Larger SUVs with powerful engines generally have lower fuel economy than minivans unless you buy an eco-friendly electric vehicle or hybrid model.

Towing capability

If towing capacity is a significant factor for your family, the best option is getting an SUV. Minivans are not designed for heavy towing because their maximum towing capacity is 3500 lbs. Conversely, SUVs, especially larger models, have significantly higher towing capacities, reaching 8000 lbs. This makes them ideal for hauling trailers, boats, or campers.

Accessibility

One of the most attractive features of minivans is the sliding door. This, plus lower seat and ride height, is important for parents with younger kids or people with limited mobility. SUVs have a higher step-in height, which can be challenging for people who use wheelchairs. However, some have running boards.

Power terrain

Minivans have smaller, fuel-efficient engines prioritizing fuel economy over raw power. They are ideal for everyday driving but struggle with heavy loads or steep inclines.

SUVs usually come with a wider range of engine options, including more powerful engines that can handle towing and provide better acceleration. Some larger SUVs boast impressive horsepower and torque for tackling demanding terrain.

Technology

Minivans and SUVs usually have the latest features, such as a rearview camera, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, Bluetooth, smart cruise control, forward collision warning, touchscreen displays, and automatic emergency braking. However, some modern SUV features, such as heated steering wheels, massaging seats, heated and cooled seats, or even length-adjustable seats, can't be found in minivans. You might need to search a little harder, especially if you are buying an older model.

Reliability

Every buyer wants a reliable car that will run consistently with few surprises. According to J.D. Power, SUVs are more reliable than minivans. For instance, the Pacifica has a score of 63, while the Hyundai SANTA FE has a rating of 81.

Price

The final amount you pay for a car, whether in cash or through auto financing, depends on the model and trim. However, minivans usually have a lower upfront cost than most SUVs.

For instance, a large SUV such as the Chevy Suburban can cost up to $50,000, while a minivan like the Honda Odyssey starts at around $38,000. That means buying a minivan can offer a significant advantage for budget-conscious families prioritizing space and practicality.

Should you buy a minivan or an SUV

As a millennial parent, you can't go wrong with a minivan or SUV. Both cars offer plenty of space for kids and cargo, not to mention the numerous cup holders for mom's daily caffeine fix. The best vehicle to buy depends on your budget, lifestyle, priorities, and aesthetic preferences.

For instance, if you enjoy camping trips and meandering unpaved roads, an SUV might be the right choice for you. On the other hand, a minivan could be a better fit if your typical day involves driving your kids and friends home.

However, before you make your final choice, ask for an extended test drive to see how the car you are considering works for your daily life. Install car seats, park the vehicle in your garage, and allow your children to jump in and out. Observe how it feels to live with the car for a few hours, and you will easily learn whether it's the best fit for your family.